A Matter of Policy

Discussion Questions

  1. Based upon the available information, how has Jennifer changed Susan's life?
     
  2. What strategies has Susan used to cope with or adapt to Jennifer's special needs?
     
  3. How might Susan's coping style have affected others (e.g., Kathy, Julie, Jennifer, Debbie, Carmen, Susan's parents, Susan's ex-husband)?
     
  4. Did Kathy handle the issue of the fever policy in the best way? Would you have handled the situation any differently?
     
  5. Did Ron Thompson handle the situation as he should have? Why or why not?
     
  6. Was calling Susan that evening a wise move on Kathy's part?
     
  7. Did Kathy handle the telephone call to Susan in an appropriate manner? What did she say or do to facilitate a productive exchange? Could she have done anything differently to improve the exchange?
     
  8. Assume Kathy's role. It is Friday and you and Susan have decided to have lunch at a delicatessen down the street from Anthem Publishers. The purpose of the lunch meeting, as you see it, is to find out what Susan Berkowitz wants or needs before you offer alternatives.
     
    • What strategy would you use to accomplish your agenda for the meeting?
       
    • Write down at least three things (be specific) you might say to start the meeting with Susan. Which of these three do you think you would actually use and why?
       
    • Write down at least 10 questions you would like to ask Susan during the course of the lunch meeting. Write them using the actual words you think you would say if you were in Kathy's position.
       
  9. If Susan remains firm in her decision to withdraw Jennifer from the classroom program, what alternatives are available? Would you present these to Susan? If so, how would you present them?
     
  10. If Susan decides not to accept any early intervention services at the time, how would you respond?
     
  11. Does Kathy have an obligation to ensure that Susan understands the full extent of Jennifer's disabilities? Does she have a responsibility to ensure that Jennifer is receiving some form of intervention?


  12. A Matter of Policy Case Story

    


Questions About This Website?
© 2004 Peabody College at Vanderbilt University -- Case Method of Instruction
Campus Box 328 Nashville, TN 37203